Another Two Failed Colonies

Sometime two weeks ago we had some nice weather that would easily constitute some trips outside from honeybees. Disappointingly there wasn’t any activity, so I went out to knock on the hive and see what I could find. There wasn’t any noise, so I lifted up the lid and looked down into the hive. There weren’t any bees visible at all. I saw straight through to the ground underneath. Frustrated, I decided I would carry the hive in and weigh it to get a better idea of what exactly was the cause of this collapse. The lower box weighed 49.5 lbs, and the top box weighed 50.5 lbs. It doesn’t make any sense!! This colony was in a location protected from the wind, higher up in the garden (not in a cold pocket), and they had more than enough honey to get them through the winter. They didn’t even make it through December!

I haven’t been able to find my hive tool, so I can’t get into the frames and take a look at what all was going on. The hive smells sweet though, and it’s actually been nice having it in the house, haha. I will note that the bees worked very hard to glue everything together, and they even sealed the edges of the hive around the screen bottom. I’m not sure if I’ll ever be able to remove that.

My hive was definitely the stronger of the two, so I wasn’t very hopeful about my aunts hive. I went over there a few days after pulling mine inside and found that hive weighed less than 15 lbs. My aunt had a bottle of sugar water over the brood nest, but we had a cold snap that had clearly been too much for them. A large pile of bees lay at the bottom of the hive, and there were plenty of mites visible. Mites were a problem in her neighborhood last year too. I took a picture of a spot where I noticed a lot of mites, and having zoomed in on the picture a little bit more I counted 9 of them. Between starvation and mites, they didn’t stand a chance.


At this point I feel like the only sure way to have bees survive through a winter is to have more hives. I’m also considering switching over to Russian or Buckfast bees. Carniolans have had limited success in my yard. This was the first year with Italians, but two failed colonies, one of which should have been extremely successful, is discouraging. Any thoughts on Buckfast or Russian bees? I know they’ve got a reputation for being a little more aggressive, but they’re both supposed to be wonderful at overwintering in this damp/cold climate. I would love to hear your thoughts!


Tags: , , ,

7 responses to “Another Two Failed Colonies”

  1. Emily Scott says :

    So sorry to hear this, it must have been very upsetting to find. I blame those mites, there do seem to be a lot of them. We have found using a variety of treatments during the year to keep knocking them back helps, for instance a shook-swarm in spring followed by Apiguard in autumn and oxalic acid in winter. Dark bees seem to overwinter better than the yellower Italians.

  2. bdbatta says :

    Find local bees. Bees raised in your climate that have been proven to overwinter in your area will be the best.

    • willowbatel says :

      There are so few breeders in the area its almost impossible to find any. I was debating shipping some in from Canada, because those bees would be sure to overwinter here just fine. I’m definitely gonna do some digging though.

      • Brian says :

        You might try checking with some of the nearest bee clubs. Even if they are a couple hundred miles away would be better than ordering packages from one of the box stores. If all else fails maybe try some minnesota hygenics. I hear very good things other than they are a bit quicker to sting.

  3. Emma Sarah Tennant says :

    Sorry to hear of your losses, although perhaps as one door closes another one opens to try new bees. I’ve read that Buckfast have a good temper, although this can sometimes change in second or third generations if queens mate with local drones. A few beekeepers at our apiary keep Buckfast and find them gentle. Good luck whatever you choose to do.

  4. Talking With Bees says :

    Sorry to read about this. I love getting your posts. Keep it up.

    You might want to have a read of my post on Grieving for bees and leave a comment on Beekeepers Anonymous

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: